If a student obtains a 45 on the MSU Speaking Test or the ITAOI and the department wishing to hire the student feels the test result inaccurately reflects the student's speaking ability, the department may ask a Review Board to evaluate independently the student's spoken English.
The department may also request an appeal if they feel the student is close to meeting the requirement and the linguistic demands of an appointment are minimal and do not require a score of 50 (e.g., for a small recitation or lab assignment). If this is the case, the department representative should come to the appeal session prepared to discuss the details of the student’s role in the intended assignment. This process makes it possible to employ a student who might otherwise not pass the speaking test outright by matching that student to a position for which their current level of oral proficiency would be adequate.
If a student is not being considered for a Teaching Assistantship for the upcoming semester, the appeal request may be denied, in which case the student will be asked to retest. Each hiring department may also request an appeal for a student who received a 40, but only for one such case per academic year (August – July), and that student can have no subsequent reviews by any department unless he or she retests and scores 45.
There are two exceptions to the policy of a minimum requirement of 50 to be a TA with no assignment restrictions:
The first exception is for TAs assigned to foreign language classes conducted primarily in the target language, in which case the required score on the MSU Speaking Test or ITAOI is 45, and candidates scoring 40 will be automatically eligible for an appeal that will not count toward the department’s one allowable 40 per academic year.
The second exception is that the speaking proficiency requirement will be waived for applied music studio TAs under the following three conditions:
- The instruction is one-on-one and primarily demonstration based.
- Mandatory, close faculty supervision is provided for the first semester.
- The TA’s performance is evaluated after each semester of instruction.
The Review Board will consist of (a) a departmental representative with faculty status (b) two ELC representatives, and (c) a representative of The Graduate School. The Graduate Director of the student’s hiring department must request the review on the student’s behalf. The Review Board can grant interviewees a full or partial waiver to teach. They can also make a determination that interviewees’ language skills do not merit any waiver.
Requests for appeals must be made within 2 weeks of the date the score was reported or within no more than 1 week of the first day of classes, whichever is earlier.
The Review Board will consist of (a) a departmental representative with faculty status (b) two ELC representatives, and (c) a representative of The Graduate School. The Graduate Director of the student’s hiring department must request the review on the student’s behalf. The Review Board can grant interviewees a full or partial waiver to teach. They can also make a determination that interviewees’ language skills do not merit any waiver.